About

ABOUT

About Restaurant

South Buffalo is home

Pubs have always been places to gather and chat. South Buffalo is our home and we want to convey its warmth and character in this neighborhood pub. From the Early Times to the Blackthorn, we have grown with our friends. We invite new friends to join us and see what they’ve been missing.

The people, after all, are the heart and soul of the pub. The pub patron is not just a customer, but a guest and a friend.

The pub opened as the Early Times Tavern and took the Blackthorn name in 1994. Pat Lalley and Hugger Adymy took it on in 2006, and the room has kept much the same feel ever since — hardwood, green Irish accents, and a stone fireplace going in the cold months.

South Buffalo has been an Irish neighborhood since families settled here at the turn of the century, and Seneca Street has always been the way into the city. We’re glad to be part of the stretch that’s come back to life.

The Blackthorn has been featured on the Food Network’s Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, and is one of fourteen stops on the Buffalo Wing Trail. The Triple D Platter on our menu is still there because people keep ordering it.

Members of the Blackthorn Club in top hats and sashes outside The Blackthorn on Seneca Street

1917

Founding of The Blackthorns.

An Irish-American fraternal and social organization is founded in South Buffalo, establishing a tradition of monthly community gatherings that continues for decades.

Pen sketch of the Early Times Tavern building, the pub before it became The Blackthorn

1976

Opening of Early Times Tavern.

Opening of Early Times Tavern - The tavern officially opens its doors at 2134 Seneca Street, quickly becoming a popular gathering spot for the local neighborhood.

The Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub old logo with a blackthorn stick and shamrocks

1994

Rebranding to The Blackthorn.

Danny Nostrant and Kevin Gould had been managing Early Times and Early Times in the Park and they got together and opened The Blackthorn in 1994

Two men smiling behind the bar in front of shelves of bottles, in a photo dated 2002

2001

Kevin Lalley Joins Danny Nostrant.

Kevin Lalley joins The Blackthorn as co-owner after bartending for years at The Blackthorn.

Man holding a baby in a red checked shirt behind the bar

2002

Passing of Kevin Lalley.

Beloved proprietor Kevin Lalley passes away at age 32.

Two men behind the bar at The Blackthorn, one pulling a draft beer from the tap

2006

Next Generation Takes the Helm.

Pat Lalley and Larry "Hugger" Adymy take over ownership, expanding the venue into an acclaimed neighborhood institution known for banquets, beer gardens, and Buffalo-style wings.